Turtle lawsuit to remove gill nets still on track

Craig Holt

January 05, 2010 at 3:14 pm  | Mobile Reader | Pring this storyPrint 

Green sea turtles often are caught by gill nets in N.C. coastal waters.
Photo courtesy NOAA
Green sea turtles often are caught by gill nets in N.C. coastal waters.
The Karen Beasley Sea Turtle Rescue and Rehabilitation Center of Topsail Island expected to file a lawsuit sometime during January aimed at removing gill nets from North Carolina coastal waters.

The Beasley Center, which rehabilitates injured sea turtles and keeps monthly records of snared North Carolina turtles, contends gill nets have been harming these endangered and threatened animals for years in violation of Section 10 of the Endangered Species Act (ESA).

Several North Carolina fishermen’s organizations, including the Coastal Fisheries Reform Group, support the center’s lawsuit, noting gill nets, in addition to killing and maiming sea turtles, also ensnare sea birds and unintentionally kill thousands of sportfish species.

On Oct. 19, the Beasley Center filed a notice of intent to sue within 60 days to several federal agencies, including the Departments of Commerce and Interior, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration along with the North Carolina Marine Fisheries Commission and North Carolina Division of Marine Fisheries.

That meant the suit could not be filed before a 60-day waiting period, not that the suit would be filed exactly 60 days after Oct. 19 (which would have been Dec. 20).

Jean Beasley, current director of the Karen Beasley Sea Turtle Rescue Center and mother of the late organization founder Karen Beasley, said she expects the suit will be filed during January with the help of the Duke Environmental Law & Policy Clinic, headed by Michelle Nowlin. The Duke group is handling the legal paperwork as a pro bono student project.

DMF director Dr. Louis Daniel, while saying he couldn’t comment on the exact response of his agency, nonetheless noted a rebuttal is being prepared.

“We have been in contact and are working closely with National Marine Fisheries Service and will have something probably to release to the public in the next few weeks,” Daniel said during a Dec. 28 interview. “But it takes time to put together documenation that everything (DMF/MFC) is doing that meets the letter of the (ESA).”

Daniel said he will send a letter to NMFS southeast regional Director Roy Crabtree telling him what DMF/MFC needs to do to answer the suit's charges.

“We hope to sit down with everyone, and I’m hoping what we propose will be a legitimate and defensible stand,” Daniel said. “I just can’t say at this time what (the response) will be.”

It's likely DMF/MFC will claim they have followed ESA law when it comes to allowing incidental netting of sea turtles.
Daniel noted that a potential glitch in the ESA allows states to have incidental interactions with sea turtles in order to sustain traditional fisheries, such as netting of flounder, yet Section 9 of the ESA also declares no one can have any interactions that “harass, harm, pursue, hunt, shoot, wound, kill, trap, capture, or collect, or to attempt to engage in any such conduct” when it affects endangered or threatened species.

“But there’s a thing called an Incidental Capture Permit (ICP), and it was created by NMFS,” Daniel said.

Basically an ICP allows “interactions” with a quota of protected animals during a certain period of time (usually a month or year) because the population of those creatures is large enough to withstand some losses without harm to the total population.

“The (U.S.) Army has an ICP at Camp Lejeune involving (protected) red-cockaded woodpeckers,” Daniel said. “NMFS also allows 350,000 total interactions with sea turtles by South Atlantic (states) fish trawlers.”

DMF obtained an ICP in 2009 for 120 green sea turtles inside Pamlico Sound and closed the flounder fishery when that number was reached a few days after the lawsuit was announced.

Daniel believes his agency is following ESA mandates.

“The $64,000 question is the (ESA) says ‘no interaction,’ but then NMFS came up with the ICP (which allows interactions),” Daniel said. “So where do you draw the line?”

However, the Beasley Center lawsuit also notes DMF/MFC is responsible for net interactions with sea turtles in all North Carolina waters and has allowed gill nets to injure and kill sea turtles outside the Pamlico Sound ICP area — which the lawsuit claims proves negligence.

As part of the ICP, state netters also are supposed to report interactions with sea turtles, and DMF is responsible for enforcing that rule. Yet no anglers reported any snared sea turtles from 2005 through 2008, even though independent observers did report such encounters, which leads to another negligence charge.

Sources indicate the Beasley Center will not accept tweaking of current netting rules by DMF/MFC but will insist on the eradication of gill nets in all North Carolina coastal waters.

“Gill nets don’t just affect turtles but waterfowl and other (endangered) creatures such as Atlantic sturgeon and diamondback turtles,” Beasley said. “Gill nets cause decimation of North Carolina’s wildlife resources.”


View other articles written Craig Holt


Reports / Forum
Sport fishing Happy Day Today  This report contains photos  
April 17 at 10:39 am | 1061 Views | 0 Comments
Heaviest bird yet  This report contains photos  
April 19 at 9:31 am | 731 Views | 0 Comments
Take a tree stand, please  This report contains photos  
April 20 at 1:21 pm | 729 Views | 0 Comments
Autumn Evans first Turkey its a family Tradition  This report contains photos  
April 17 at 8:03 pm | 691 Views | 2 Comments
Catawba Catfish Club Lake Wateree,SC 5-3-14 Tournament 
April 19 at 5:15 pm | 623 Views | 0 Comments
TAGGED OUT!!  This report contains photos  
April 17 at 6:43 am | 619 Views | 2 Comments
Double with Golden  This report contains photos  
April 21 at 7:45 pm | 523 Views | 0 Comments
weyerhaeuser hunting land 
April 19 at 2:12 pm | 509 Views | 0 Comments
Youth Day  This report contains photos  
April 17 at 11:10 am | 491 Views | 1 Comments
GT and Viper 
April 21 at 7:46 pm | 415 Views | 4 Comments
First turkey and with a bow!  This report contains photos  
April 21 at 3:29 pm | 391 Views | 0 Comments
Boats Unlimited NC Team Trail Q4 results..Falls Lake..Apr. 12th  This report contains photos  
April 18 at 6:15 am | 363 Views | 0 Comments
Golden Wings  This report contains photos  
April 21 at 7:42 pm | 331 Views | 0 Comments
Paisley's first turkey 
April 18 at 10:59 am | 323 Views | 0 Comments
Cold, Rainy and Windy Tough on Fishing 
April 20 at 2:23 pm | 303 Views | 0 Comments
Fishing Happy Day Today  This report contains photos  
April 21 at 9:18 am | 261 Views | 0 Comments
taking the boat and 2 year old out(high rock lake) 
April 19 at 1:55 pm | 235 Views | 0 Comments
First Gobbler!  This report contains photos  
7 hours ago | 49 Views | 0 Comments
Tagged Out!  This report contains photos  
7 hours ago | 45 Views | 0 Comments
Post | Reports | Forum
GT and Viper 
April 21 at 7:46 pm | 415 Views | 4 Comments
Autumn Evans first Turkey its a family Tradition  This report contains photos  
April 17 at 8:03 pm | 691 Views | 2 Comments
TAGGED OUT!!  This report contains photos  
April 17 at 6:43 am | 619 Views | 2 Comments
Youth Day  This report contains photos  
April 17 at 11:10 am | 491 Views | 1 Comments
Tagged Out!  This report contains photos  
7 hours ago | 45 Views | 0 Comments
First Gobbler!  This report contains photos  
7 hours ago | 49 Views | 0 Comments
Golden Wings  This report contains photos  
April 21 at 7:42 pm | 331 Views | 0 Comments
First turkey and with a bow!  This report contains photos  
April 21 at 3:29 pm | 391 Views | 0 Comments
Fishing Happy Day Today  This report contains photos  
April 21 at 9:18 am | 261 Views | 0 Comments
Cold, Rainy and Windy Tough on Fishing 
April 20 at 2:23 pm | 303 Views | 0 Comments
Take a tree stand, please  This report contains photos  
April 20 at 1:21 pm | 729 Views | 0 Comments
Catawba Catfish Club Lake Wateree,SC 5-3-14 Tournament 
April 19 at 5:15 pm | 623 Views | 0 Comments
weyerhaeuser hunting land 
April 19 at 2:12 pm | 509 Views | 0 Comments
taking the boat and 2 year old out(high rock lake) 
April 19 at 1:55 pm | 235 Views | 0 Comments
Heaviest bird yet  This report contains photos  
April 19 at 9:31 am | 731 Views | 0 Comments
Paisley's first turkey 
April 18 at 10:59 am | 323 Views | 0 Comments
Boats Unlimited NC Team Trail Q4 results..Falls Lake..Apr. 12th  This report contains photos  
April 18 at 6:15 am | 363 Views | 0 Comments
Sport fishing Happy Day Today  This report contains photos  
April 17 at 10:39 am | 1061 Views | 0 Comments
Double with Golden  This report contains photos  
April 21 at 7:45 pm | 523 Views | 0 Comments
Post | Reports | Forum
Tagged Out!  This report contains photos  
7 hours ago | 45 Views | 0 Comments
First Gobbler!  This report contains photos  
7 hours ago | 49 Views | 0 Comments
GT and Viper 
April 21 at 7:46 pm | 415 Views | 4 Comments
Double with Golden  This report contains photos  
April 21 at 7:45 pm | 523 Views | 0 Comments
Golden Wings  This report contains photos  
April 21 at 7:42 pm | 331 Views | 0 Comments
First turkey and with a bow!  This report contains photos  
April 21 at 3:29 pm | 391 Views | 0 Comments
Fishing Happy Day Today  This report contains photos  
April 21 at 9:18 am | 261 Views | 0 Comments
Cold, Rainy and Windy Tough on Fishing 
April 20 at 2:23 pm | 303 Views | 0 Comments
Take a tree stand, please  This report contains photos  
April 20 at 1:21 pm | 729 Views | 0 Comments
Catawba Catfish Club Lake Wateree,SC 5-3-14 Tournament 
April 19 at 5:15 pm | 623 Views | 0 Comments
weyerhaeuser hunting land 
April 19 at 2:12 pm | 509 Views | 0 Comments
taking the boat and 2 year old out(high rock lake) 
April 19 at 1:55 pm | 235 Views | 0 Comments
Heaviest bird yet  This report contains photos  
April 19 at 9:31 am | 731 Views | 0 Comments
Paisley's first turkey 
April 18 at 10:59 am | 323 Views | 0 Comments
Boats Unlimited NC Team Trail Q4 results..Falls Lake..Apr. 12th  This report contains photos  
April 18 at 6:15 am | 363 Views | 0 Comments
Autumn Evans first Turkey its a family Tradition  This report contains photos  
April 17 at 8:03 pm | 691 Views | 2 Comments
Youth Day  This report contains photos  
April 17 at 11:10 am | 491 Views | 1 Comments
Sport fishing Happy Day Today  This report contains photos  
April 17 at 10:39 am | 1061 Views | 0 Comments
TAGGED OUT!!  This report contains photos  
April 17 at 6:43 am | 619 Views | 2 Comments
Post | Reports | Forum

Free Classifieds

G3 Gator Tough 1860 CC Tunnel
G3 Gator Tough 1860 CC Tunnel
70hp Yamaha 4 stroke with 6' jack plate, only 25 hours. 2012 custom fit float on/off trailer w/removable tongue, Mossy oak W/ Bimini top. Fish finder, GPS, 55lb Min Kota trolling motor, live well, cooler bench seat with leaning post, two lockable...
April 19 at 11:35 am | 157 Views
Baby Desert Eagle 40 S&W for $250
Baby Desert Eagle 40 S&W for $250
Excellent Desert Eagle 40 caliber Hand Gun For Sale,6 ' barrel,semi rnrnautomatic,& made by Magnum Research,right here in the USA,& comes with 1-7 rnrnround magazine, super heavy duty fitted carry case with soft rummer rnrninside,take down...
April 20 at 3:18 am | 52 Views
Still Hunting Deer Club
Still Hunting Deer Club
Membership available in still hunting deer club for the 2014-15 season. Club has almost 4,000 acres of leased land and owns 55 acres with a two story club house. Club is located in Warren county about 5 miles from Littleton. Club dues are $725.00....
April 21 at 7:43 am | 114 Views
Baby Desert Eagle 40 S&W for $250
Baby Desert Eagle 40 S&W for $250
Excellent Desert Eagle 40 caliber Hand Gun For Sale,6 ' barrel,semi rnrnautomatic,& made by Magnum Research,right here in the USA,& comes with 1-7 rnrnround magazine, super heavy duty fitted carry case with soft rummer rnrninside,take down...
April 20 at 3:13 am | 33 Views
NEW REMINGTON 870 TACTICAL/ULTIMATE COMBAT SHOTGUN
NEW REMINGTON 870 TACTICAL/ULTIMATE COMBAT SHOTGUN
This new 870 was built for one purpose to save your life or your family's. It has form function and reliability. Has a Mesa Tactical recoil reducing 6 position stock. There is no felt recoil even with 3 inch buck plus the stock is comfortable in...
15 hours ago | 20 Views
MDBR Hunting Club has 4 openings!
MDBR Hunting Club has 4 openings!
MDBR Hunting Club is a small 10 member club with a 350 acre lease near Gulf, NC (Chatham County). No Dog Hunting in Chatham county! Very peaceful area! Membership dues pay for lease & insurance. Anyone interested should visit our website at...
Yesterday at 1:41 pm | 28 Views