Questions about oil dispersant drive Louisiana fishing closures, some fisheries could collaps


May 27, 2010 at 10:28 am  | Mobile Reader | Pring this storyPrint 

Oil has been staining Louisiana's fragile marshes for almost a month now, and anglers have become frustrated with constantly changing closures and openings.
Photo by Ann Taylor
Oil has been staining Louisiana's fragile marshes for almost a month now, and anglers have become frustrated with constantly changing closures and openings.
While many Louisiana anglers have expressed frustration with a string of fishing closures and reopenings following the BP Gulf of Mexico oil spill, Louisiana Department of Wildlife and Fisheries head Robert Barham said there is method to the madness.

“When we have an imminent projection of oil into the area or a verified report that oil is in the area, we close it,” Barham told LouisianaSportsman yesterday (May 25).

For instance, Barataria Bay was shut down in two orders issued about four hours apart over the weekend. The LDWF chief said that was due to the actual presence of oil – a testament to the fact that National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration forecasts aren’t always exact.

“We did not expect that oil to come inside Barataria Bay,” Barham said. “Oil came in, and we found it in multiple locations.”

The first confirmed report of oil led to the initial closure of the southeastern corner of the basin, but when oil was found in more northerly waters, Barham gave the order to shut the entire system down to a point just north of Bay Wilkinson.

Once an area is closed, sampling of seafood is stepped up to ensure there is no contamination, and monitoring of the oil begins to understand how the gooey mess will move around in the affected system.

Once managers are comfortable that waters are no longer affected by oil, a reopenings are announced. But it’s not an overnight reversal.

“Generally for about seven days we monitor the presence or absence of oil,” Barham explained. “After that seven days, we send biologists out to find the presence of oil, and if they don’t find any, the area is reopened.”

However, he hurried to say that this seven-day period isn’t “carved in stone.”

Trout, redfish clean; Corexit main concern

Barham has been clear on the intent of these closures since enacting the first shut-downs east of the Mississippi River after oil began pouring into the Gulf of Mexico.

“I signed this emergency closure … as a proactive effort to prevent any oil-tainted fish, shrimp or crab from being caught and thus consumed,” Barham said at the time.

And there has been some contaminated commercial seafood found, although Barham admitted that none of the redfish or trout sampled came back positive for hydrocarbon contamination.

At the same time, experts have told LouisianaSportsman.com that there is no health threat from consumption of hydrocarbon-contaminated fish.

“It’s not a toxicity issue for people, per se. The seafood just doesn’t taste good,” retired LSU professor Ed Overton said. “It’s a consumption-quality issue.”

In other words, a contaminated fish would taste so bad that it would be inedible – so no harm would be done.

And Barham even admitted in yesterday’s interview that it was unlikely those gamefish Louisiana anglers love to chase would be polluted with hydrocarbons.

“Fish are going to avoid it if they can,” he said.

So why has recreational fishing been lumped in with commercial fishing operations, which could introduce large quantities of contaminated seafood into an unsuspecting public market?

After all, there are waters across the state still open to recreational fishing despite the confirmed presence of mercury in fish. In those instances, anglers are left to make an educated decision whether or not to fish those waters.

It all boils down to the scientific knowledge of mercury versus the oil dispersant Corexit, which is being used in large quantities by BP on the surface and at the source of the leak in defiance of orders from federal officials to at least reduce the amount used.

“There is a published tolerance for mercury consumption: There is no published tolerance for Corexit in mixture with hydrocarbons,” Barham said. “Until the EPA gives us the tolerance levels for consumption of Corexit, we cannot risk the public threat.”

Therefore, he said the only option is to shut down fishing wherever oil – and thus the threat of Corexit – is found.

“It’s not an option to put up a sign to fish at your own risk,” he said.

To report oil, call 866.448.5816.

Barham said he has requested information on Corexit studies from BP, and will talk with the head of Corexit manufacturer Nalco Company today (May 26).

In addition, he said LSU is set to begin work on a study – paid for by BP – to determine clearly what, if any, public health threat is posed from the dispersant.

Mum on length of closures, long-term impacts certain

Those words and some experts’ prediction that oil could be washing ashore 10 years from now even if the leak is plugged today sound less than promising about the future of fishing along much of Louisiana’s coast, but Barham refused to discuss the possibility that closures could plague the state for years to come.

“I’m not going to speculate on that,” he said. “There will be a day (when he will), but today’s not that day.”

However, Barham said he was realistic about the potential long-term impact of the spill.

“This is sort of an unprecedented event; my crystal ball is a bit hazy,” he said. “But I think you will have some areas, especially in the oyster-producing zones, that will be destroyed.”

He said he fully expects some oyster grounds will have to be abandoned because of contamination and reestablished in other areas.

Most frightening to Louisiana anglers is the threat of collapse of some fisheries, which Barham said is very real possibility.

“If the oil affects a species that other fish rely upon, it is possible you can have a collapse of that portion of the fishing industry,” Barham said.

He pointed to the Alaska experience following the 1989 Exxon Valdez spill as proof that large oil spills have lasting impacts.

“The herring industry collapsed,” Barham said.

That collapse was apparent soon after the spill, but Barham


View other articles written Andy Crawford


Reports / Forum
Take a tree stand, please  This report contains photos  
April 20 at 1:21 pm | 923 Views | 1 Comments
Heaviest bird yet  This report contains photos  
April 19 at 9:31 am | 833 Views | 0 Comments
Catawba Catfish Club Lake Wateree,SC 5-3-14 Tournament 
April 19 at 5:15 pm | 755 Views | 0 Comments
Double with Golden  This report contains photos  
April 21 at 7:45 pm | 649 Views | 1 Comments
weyerhaeuser hunting land 
April 19 at 2:12 pm | 605 Views | 0 Comments
GT and Viper 
April 21 at 7:46 pm | 573 Views | 5 Comments
First turkey and with a bow!  This report contains photos  
April 21 at 3:29 pm | 527 Views | 1 Comments
Golden Wings  This report contains photos  
April 21 at 7:42 pm | 405 Views | 0 Comments
Boats Unlimited NC Team Trail Q4 results..Falls Lake..Apr. 12th  This report contains photos  
April 18 at 6:15 am | 393 Views | 0 Comments
Paisley's first turkey 
April 18 at 10:59 am | 353 Views | 0 Comments
Cold, Rainy and Windy Tough on Fishing 
April 20 at 2:23 pm | 341 Views | 0 Comments
Fishing Happy Day Today  This report contains photos  
April 21 at 9:18 am | 297 Views | 0 Comments
Tagged Out!  This report contains photos  
Yesterday at 8:54 pm | 293 Views | 1 Comments
taking the boat and 2 year old out(high rock lake) 
April 19 at 1:55 pm | 263 Views | 0 Comments
First Gobbler!  This report contains photos  
Yesterday at 8:44 pm | 245 Views | 1 Comments
Redfish Limits  This report contains photos  
3 hours ago | 27 Views | 0 Comments
Post | Reports | Forum
GT and Viper 
April 21 at 7:46 pm | 573 Views | 5 Comments
Tagged Out!  This report contains photos  
Yesterday at 8:54 pm | 293 Views | 1 Comments
First Gobbler!  This report contains photos  
Yesterday at 8:44 pm | 245 Views | 1 Comments
First turkey and with a bow!  This report contains photos  
April 21 at 3:29 pm | 527 Views | 1 Comments
Take a tree stand, please  This report contains photos  
April 20 at 1:21 pm | 923 Views | 1 Comments
Double with Golden  This report contains photos  
April 21 at 7:45 pm | 649 Views | 1 Comments
Redfish Limits  This report contains photos  
3 hours ago | 27 Views | 0 Comments
Golden Wings  This report contains photos  
April 21 at 7:42 pm | 405 Views | 0 Comments
Fishing Happy Day Today  This report contains photos  
April 21 at 9:18 am | 297 Views | 0 Comments
Cold, Rainy and Windy Tough on Fishing 
April 20 at 2:23 pm | 341 Views | 0 Comments
Catawba Catfish Club Lake Wateree,SC 5-3-14 Tournament 
April 19 at 5:15 pm | 755 Views | 0 Comments
weyerhaeuser hunting land 
April 19 at 2:12 pm | 605 Views | 0 Comments
taking the boat and 2 year old out(high rock lake) 
April 19 at 1:55 pm | 263 Views | 0 Comments
Heaviest bird yet  This report contains photos  
April 19 at 9:31 am | 833 Views | 0 Comments
Paisley's first turkey 
April 18 at 10:59 am | 353 Views | 0 Comments
Boats Unlimited NC Team Trail Q4 results..Falls Lake..Apr. 12th  This report contains photos  
April 18 at 6:15 am | 393 Views | 0 Comments
Post | Reports | Forum
Redfish Limits  This report contains photos  
3 hours ago | 27 Views | 0 Comments
Tagged Out!  This report contains photos  
Yesterday at 8:54 pm | 293 Views | 1 Comments
First Gobbler!  This report contains photos  
Yesterday at 8:44 pm | 245 Views | 1 Comments
GT and Viper 
April 21 at 7:46 pm | 573 Views | 5 Comments
Double with Golden  This report contains photos  
April 21 at 7:45 pm | 649 Views | 1 Comments
Golden Wings  This report contains photos  
April 21 at 7:42 pm | 405 Views | 0 Comments
First turkey and with a bow!  This report contains photos  
April 21 at 3:29 pm | 527 Views | 1 Comments
Fishing Happy Day Today  This report contains photos  
April 21 at 9:18 am | 297 Views | 0 Comments
Cold, Rainy and Windy Tough on Fishing 
April 20 at 2:23 pm | 341 Views | 0 Comments
Take a tree stand, please  This report contains photos  
April 20 at 1:21 pm | 923 Views | 1 Comments
Catawba Catfish Club Lake Wateree,SC 5-3-14 Tournament 
April 19 at 5:15 pm | 755 Views | 0 Comments
weyerhaeuser hunting land 
April 19 at 2:12 pm | 605 Views | 0 Comments
taking the boat and 2 year old out(high rock lake) 
April 19 at 1:55 pm | 263 Views | 0 Comments
Heaviest bird yet  This report contains photos  
April 19 at 9:31 am | 833 Views | 0 Comments
Paisley's first turkey 
April 18 at 10:59 am | 353 Views | 0 Comments
Boats Unlimited NC Team Trail Q4 results..Falls Lake..Apr. 12th  This report contains photos  
April 18 at 6:15 am | 393 Views | 0 Comments
Post | Reports | Forum

Free Classifieds

NEW REMINGTON 870 TACTICAL/ULTIMATE COMBAT SHOTGUN
NEW REMINGTON 870 TACTICAL/ULTIMATE COMBAT SHOTGUN
This new 870 was built for one purpose to save your life or your family's. It has form function and reliability. Has a Mesa Tactical recoil reducing 6 position stock. There is no felt recoil even with 3 inch buck plus the stock is comfortable in...
Yesterday at 12:46 pm | 26 Views
2009 Yamaha RHINO 700 SPORT Package Very Rare
2009 Yamaha RHINO 700 SPORT Package Very Rare
LIMITED SPECIAL EDITION (INCLUDING SPORT PACKAGE OPTION HAS BETTERrnSHOCKS WITH PIGY BAGS THAN STOCK RHINO PLUS HAS UPGRADED STEERINGrnWHEEL AND SHIFTER ALL OEM CAME FROM YAMAHA ) YAMAHA, S ULTRAMATICrnV-BELT TRANSMISSION ,VERY WELL PROVEN IN LONG...
4 hours ago | 12 Views
G3 Gator Tough 1860 CC Tunnel
G3 Gator Tough 1860 CC Tunnel
70hp Yamaha 4 stroke with 6' jack plate, only 25 hours. 2012 custom fit float on/off trailer w/removable tongue, Mossy oak W/ Bimini top. Fish finder, GPS, 55lb Min Kota trolling motor, live well, cooler bench seat with leaning post, two lockable...
April 19 at 11:35 am | 170 Views
Still Hunting Deer Club
Still Hunting Deer Club
Membership available in still hunting deer club for the 2014-15 season. Club has almost 4,000 acres of leased land and owns 55 acres with a two story club house. Club is located in Warren county about 5 miles from Littleton. Club dues are $725.00....
April 21 at 7:43 am | 131 Views
Baby Desert Eagle 40 S&W for $250
Baby Desert Eagle 40 S&W for $250
Excellent Desert Eagle 40 caliber Hand Gun For Sale,6 ' barrel,semi rnrnautomatic,& made by Magnum Research,right here in the USA,& comes with 1-7 rnrnround magazine, super heavy duty fitted carry case with soft rummer rnrninside,take down...
April 20 at 3:13 am | 44 Views
MDBR Hunting Club has 4 openings!
MDBR Hunting Club has 4 openings!
MDBR Hunting Club is a small 10 member club with a 350 acre lease near Gulf, NC (Chatham County). No Dog Hunting in Chatham county! Very peaceful area! Membership dues pay for lease & insurance. Anyone interested should visit our website at...
April 22 at 1:41 pm | 46 Views
Baby Desert Eagle 40 S&W for $250
Baby Desert Eagle 40 S&W for $250
Excellent Desert Eagle 40 caliber Hand Gun For Sale,6 ' barrel,semi rnrnautomatic,& made by Magnum Research,right here in the USA,& comes with 1-7 rnrnround magazine, super heavy duty fitted carry case with soft rummer rnrninside,take down...
April 20 at 3:18 am | 73 Views