Judge's decision is setback for Outer Banks beach-access supporters

NPS allowed to issue critical-habitat designation

Craig Holt

September 01, 2010 at 11:17 am  | Mobile Reader | Pring this storyPrint 

Anglers fear that surf-fishing could be curtailed severely at places such as Cape Point near Buxton if the National Park Service enforces piping plover critical habitat range.
CRAIG HOLT
Anglers fear that surf-fishing could be curtailed severely at places such as Cape Point near Buxton if the National Park Service enforces piping plover critical habitat range.
Outer Banks residents and visiting anglers who visit the Cape Hatteras National Seashore believe that flawed science is behind the federal government’s attempts to shut down public beach access.

Ironically, actions taken by the federal courts and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service are apparently creating more problems for threatened birds, according to  one long-time Outer Banks resident who is also a surf fisherman and bird watcher.

In July, District Chief Judge Royce Lamberth ruled in Washington, D.C., that the USFWS didn’t impose unnecessary restrictions or infringe on the rights of Outer Banks business owners and residents when it established “critical habitat” designation for wintering piping plovers, which area listed as “threatened” by the Endangered Species Act.


Critical- habitat designation means federal land that is home to or may become home to threatened or endangered species can’t be altered or affected in any way that would threaten the survival of those species. The bottom line is that critical-habitat designation affords another legal precedent for permanently closing sections of the OBX to human activity.


The decision was met with dismay by pro-access OBX supporters because it could lead to winter beach closures during prime fishing months and negatively affect local businesses, already hurt by a 2008 beach-access consent decree arranged by a federal judge.

Oddly enough, few piping plovers winter on North Carolina beaches, according to several experts, including Larry Hardham, the president of the Cape Hatteras Anglers Club, who also is an avid bird watcher.


“What it means is the (NPS) will feel justified in maintaining winter closures at the interiors of Cape Point and several ‘spits,’” Hardham said. “The end result of that will be the destruction of breeding habitat. It’s an extreme condition toward an ultimate goal, because that already has happened at Oregon Inlet and is happening at Cape Point.”

“Spits” include areas on both sides of Oregon Inlet, Hatteras Inlet and Ocracoke Inlet, all popular surf-fishing areas, while Cape Point is the most famous surf-fishing venue on the east coast.


Hardham pointed out only four breeding activities of plovers have been documented at Bodie Island spit (the north side of Oregon Inlet) during the last 10 years.


“In 2009, there were no breeding pairs of plovers at the spit, and in 2008 there was one nest and one pair of birds that produced no chicks. In 2007, one chick fledged,” he said.

Before land around the spit was declared off limits, plovers nested there because they prefer open sandy areas not covered by vegetation. Human activities around a man-made pond now closed to any visitation created the open areas.
Hardham said when the feds impose critical habitat on any area, the precise conditions that allow plovers to thrive all but disappear.


“What happens is because recreational use is denied, these areas grow up in vegetation,” Hardham said. “The interior of the north side of Oregon Inlet used to be open for recreational use and was a successful plover breeding ground. Now, since it’s been closed off year-round, vegetation has taken over, and no piping plovers have successfully bred there for four or five years.”


As a result, Hardham said critical habitat designation lowers bird numbers.

“The whole closure concept deals with human intervention affecting breeding activity,” he said. “But (human intervention) is well below in its impacts compared to predation and weather events.”


Hardham said recreational use of the shoreline is actually “the low man on the totem pole (affecting plovers), yet they deal with that like it’s a major cause.”

Pro-access groups — such as the Cape Hatteras Preservation Alliance (CHAPA),  comprised of clubs such as the Cape Hatteras Anglers Club, the Outer Banks Preservation Association and N.C. Beach Buggy Association — have been some of the best stewards of habitat and wildlife at the Seashore. CHAPA fought in federal courts and won a decision against the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service in 2004 when the court remanded critical-habitat designation attempts back to the FWS in order to correct errors in its defense. Chief among those was CHAPA’s charge that FWS hadn’t used good science.

“One reason CHAPA won in 2004 was that judge said FWS hadn’t done a comprehensive economic-impact study,” Hardham said. “Well, (FWS) went right back and did a rehash of the same economic study, but this time the judge approved the critical-habitat designation.”


Hardham said a peer review by the NPS of the first economic impact analysis study said, “it wasn’t of good-enough quality” to be used as an effective tool.


“A firm in Massachusetts was contacted to do the second study, but they didn’t come and didn’t talk to the first person, outside the NPS,” he said. “But they still used (the previous) results. Does that make any sense? Also, in their study, they considered the entire 24,660 acres of the seashore as potential beach-driving areas instead of the less than 1,000 acres that actually can be used.


“I think the American public deserves better than that, to use junk science to make such an important decision.” U


View other articles written Craig Holt


Reports / Forum
Opening Morning Double!!  This report contains photos  
April 14 at 8:17 am | 1071 Views | 4 Comments
First Turkey...  This report contains photos  
April 14 at 12:39 pm | 731 Views | 4 Comments
Tagged out in two days  This report contains photos  
April 16 at 11:26 am | 685 Views | 3 Comments
Twin Girls First Turkey!  This report contains photos  
April 16 at 8:51 am | 605 Views | 2 Comments
Weldon Stripers 
April 15 at 7:14 am | 589 Views | 1 Comments
opening day success  This report contains photos  
April 15 at 12:29 pm | 569 Views | 1 Comments
Autumn Evans first Turkey its a family Tradition  This report contains photos  
April 17 at 8:03 pm | 433 Views | 2 Comments
TAGGED OUT!!  This report contains photos  
April 17 at 6:43 am | 425 Views | 2 Comments
Sport fishing Happy Day Today  This report contains photos  
April 17 at 10:39 am | 373 Views | 0 Comments
First Turkey 
April 14 at 12:27 pm | 339 Views | 0 Comments
Heaviest bird yet  This report contains photos  
Yesterday at 9:31 am | 327 Views | 0 Comments
Youth Day  This report contains photos  
April 17 at 11:10 am | 305 Views | 1 Comments
Caleb's First Turkey  This report contains photos  
April 16 at 6:47 pm | 291 Views | 1 Comments
Boats Unlimited NC Team Trail Q4 results..Falls Lake..Apr. 12th  This report contains photos  
April 18 at 6:15 am | 253 Views | 0 Comments
weyerhaeuser hunting land 
Yesterday at 2:12 pm | 217 Views | 0 Comments
Paisley's first turkey 
April 18 at 10:59 am | 215 Views | 0 Comments
Catawba Catfish Club Lake Wateree,SC 5-3-14 Tournament 
Yesterday at 5:15 pm | 189 Views | 0 Comments
Take a tree stand, please  This report contains photos  
12 hours ago | 161 Views | 0 Comments
taking the boat and 2 year old out(high rock lake) 
Yesterday at 1:55 pm | 115 Views | 0 Comments
Cold, Rainy and Windy Tough on Fishing 
11 hours ago | 79 Views | 0 Comments
Post | Reports | Forum
First Turkey...  This report contains photos  
April 14 at 12:39 pm | 731 Views | 4 Comments
Opening Morning Double!!  This report contains photos  
April 14 at 8:17 am | 1071 Views | 4 Comments
Tagged out in two days  This report contains photos  
April 16 at 11:26 am | 685 Views | 3 Comments
Autumn Evans first Turkey its a family Tradition  This report contains photos  
April 17 at 8:03 pm | 433 Views | 2 Comments
TAGGED OUT!!  This report contains photos  
April 17 at 6:43 am | 425 Views | 2 Comments
Twin Girls First Turkey!  This report contains photos  
April 16 at 8:51 am | 605 Views | 2 Comments
Youth Day  This report contains photos  
April 17 at 11:10 am | 305 Views | 1 Comments
Caleb's First Turkey  This report contains photos  
April 16 at 6:47 pm | 291 Views | 1 Comments
opening day success  This report contains photos  
April 15 at 12:29 pm | 569 Views | 1 Comments
Weldon Stripers 
April 15 at 7:14 am | 589 Views | 1 Comments
Cold, Rainy and Windy Tough on Fishing 
11 hours ago | 79 Views | 0 Comments
Take a tree stand, please  This report contains photos  
12 hours ago | 161 Views | 0 Comments
Catawba Catfish Club Lake Wateree,SC 5-3-14 Tournament 
Yesterday at 5:15 pm | 189 Views | 0 Comments
weyerhaeuser hunting land 
Yesterday at 2:12 pm | 217 Views | 0 Comments
taking the boat and 2 year old out(high rock lake) 
Yesterday at 1:55 pm | 115 Views | 0 Comments
Heaviest bird yet  This report contains photos  
Yesterday at 9:31 am | 327 Views | 0 Comments
Paisley's first turkey 
April 18 at 10:59 am | 215 Views | 0 Comments
Boats Unlimited NC Team Trail Q4 results..Falls Lake..Apr. 12th  This report contains photos  
April 18 at 6:15 am | 253 Views | 0 Comments
Sport fishing Happy Day Today  This report contains photos  
April 17 at 10:39 am | 373 Views | 0 Comments
First Turkey 
April 14 at 12:27 pm | 339 Views | 0 Comments
Post | Reports | Forum
Cold, Rainy and Windy Tough on Fishing 
11 hours ago | 79 Views | 0 Comments
Take a tree stand, please  This report contains photos  
12 hours ago | 161 Views | 0 Comments
Catawba Catfish Club Lake Wateree,SC 5-3-14 Tournament 
Yesterday at 5:15 pm | 189 Views | 0 Comments
weyerhaeuser hunting land 
Yesterday at 2:12 pm | 217 Views | 0 Comments
taking the boat and 2 year old out(high rock lake) 
Yesterday at 1:55 pm | 115 Views | 0 Comments
Heaviest bird yet  This report contains photos  
Yesterday at 9:31 am | 327 Views | 0 Comments
Paisley's first turkey 
April 18 at 10:59 am | 215 Views | 0 Comments
Boats Unlimited NC Team Trail Q4 results..Falls Lake..Apr. 12th  This report contains photos  
April 18 at 6:15 am | 253 Views | 0 Comments
Autumn Evans first Turkey its a family Tradition  This report contains photos  
April 17 at 8:03 pm | 433 Views | 2 Comments
Youth Day  This report contains photos  
April 17 at 11:10 am | 305 Views | 1 Comments
Sport fishing Happy Day Today  This report contains photos  
April 17 at 10:39 am | 373 Views | 0 Comments
TAGGED OUT!!  This report contains photos  
April 17 at 6:43 am | 425 Views | 2 Comments
Caleb's First Turkey  This report contains photos  
April 16 at 6:47 pm | 291 Views | 1 Comments
Tagged out in two days  This report contains photos  
April 16 at 11:26 am | 685 Views | 3 Comments
Twin Girls First Turkey!  This report contains photos  
April 16 at 8:51 am | 605 Views | 2 Comments
opening day success  This report contains photos  
April 15 at 12:29 pm | 569 Views | 1 Comments
Weldon Stripers 
April 15 at 7:14 am | 589 Views | 1 Comments
First Turkey...  This report contains photos  
April 14 at 12:39 pm | 731 Views | 4 Comments
First Turkey 
April 14 at 12:27 pm | 339 Views | 0 Comments
Opening Morning Double!!  This report contains photos  
April 14 at 8:17 am | 1071 Views | 4 Comments
Post | Reports | Forum

Free Classifieds

G3 Gator Tough 1860 CC Tunnel
G3 Gator Tough 1860 CC Tunnel
70hp Yamaha 4 stroke with 6' jack plate, only 25 hours. 2012 custom fit float on/off trailer w/removable tongue, Mossy oak W/ Bimini top. Fish finder, GPS, 55lb Min Kota trolling motor, live well, cooler bench seat with leaning post, two lockable...
Yesterday at 11:35 am | 60 Views
1998 Jeep Wrangler Sport 4x4
1998 Jeep Wrangler Sport 4x4
Very good condition 1998 Jeep Wrangler Sport. It has been very wellrnkept. It appears to have always been garaged and only driven on cityrnstreets and not been offroaded. This Jeep was owned and cared for by arnperson who appreciated nice things....
April 17 at 5:06 pm | 56 Views
Baby Desert Eagle 40 S&W for $250
Baby Desert Eagle 40 S&W for $250
Excellent Desert Eagle 40 caliber Hand Gun For Sale,6 ' barrel,semi rnrnautomatic,& made by Magnum Research,right here in the USA,& comes with 1-7 rnrnround magazine, super heavy duty fitted carry case with soft rummer rnrninside,take down...
22 hours ago | 15 Views
Brand New Carbon Express Cross Bow
Brand New Carbon Express Cross Bow
This is a brand new bow in the box never been opened never been fired. It is a Carbon Express X-Force 400 Cross Bow. It is a complete package with Rope Cocker and Rail Lube, 4x32 Deluxe Scope, Quick detach 3 arrow quiver, 3 20' crossbolts and 3...
April 15 at 7:38 pm | 46 Views
Late 60\'s Early 70\'s Zabala 20 Gauge Double Barrell
Late 60\'s Early 70\'s Zabala 20 Gauge Double Barrell
Late 60's Early 70's Eagle Arms by Zabala 20 Gauge Double Barrel Shotgun. 26' Barrel, 3' shells. This gun was handed down to me and I am not a gun enthusiast, so do not have a need for it. Can provide more pics, info if necessary. Email...
April 16 at 5:30 pm | 90 Views
GUN HUNTS IN KANSAS
GUN HUNTS IN KANSAS
Only a few days left to get your Kansas deer hunting license & permits. Last day to apply is April 24th. I have 3-4 spots available for the exciting gun season Dec 8th thru Dec 14th. Come hunt with me in 'The Land of Giants' on privately managed...
April 14 at 10:51 pm | 56 Views
Baby Desert Eagle 40 S&W for $250
Baby Desert Eagle 40 S&W for $250
Excellent Desert Eagle 40 caliber Hand Gun For Sale,6 ' barrel,semi rnrnautomatic,& made by Magnum Research,right here in the USA,& comes with 1-7 rnrnround magazine, super heavy duty fitted carry case with soft rummer rnrninside,take down...
22 hours ago | 9 Views
Wanted anything Dan Wesson.
Wanted anything Dan Wesson.
Looking for revolvers anything Dan Wesson, thanks please call Will at 919-937-7687...
April 16 at 5:04 pm | 20 Views